Pension Risk Matters

Sub-Prime Losses Keep Coming

At this rate, one could spend hours blogging about sub-prime woes, risk and whether adequate controls were in place. In a December 4, 2007 Washington Post article entitled "Losses Stack Up: Local Officials in Florida Try to Assess Damage To Investments Linked to Soured Subprime Loans " by Tomoeh Murakami Tse, I was interviewed about pension risk management implications. (Click here to access the article. You may be asked to register.) The State Board of Administration of Florida itself acknowledges the importance of risk controls, both in a November 2007 account of their sub-prime losses and in later interviews about fund withdrawals, subsequent freezes prohibiting further withdrawals and the hiring of Blackrock to develop a financial game plan.

In a recent study by the Towers Group, risk management was found to be lacking at some organizations, arguably one cause for large losses. Describing the adverse consequences of siloed risk management functions in financial institutions, authors of "Multifunctional Integration: The Positive Side of Risk," cite the need to work across divisions. They add that  "Beyond defending against threats to the organization, a more integrated approach to risk management can drive other business and client-centric benefits, including: improved quality and transparency of information; relationship pricing; process simplicity and efficiency; more effective decision making; and overall resilience."

No surprise to this risk manager and blogger who has spent over 20 years in the areas of risk management consulting, forensic analysis, board and trustee training and process assessment. In trying to convey the importance of acting before the fact, our Pension Governance team oft-repeats the importance of a holistic investment risk orientation, commencing with comprehensive training for everyone - front, middle and back office staff included. Importantly, buy-in from the top drives the acceptance of an organizational-wide risk culture and allows for resources to purchase analytical systems, hire professionals and make sure everyone has a good understanding of checks and balances. (In a recent workshop I led on risk management, I encouraged pension fund professionals to spend time with the chief risk officers employed by their banks, mutual fund and hedge fund managers.) 

Whether separate risk management activity reflects a "penny wise, pound foolish" behavior depends on a host of factors and will vary across organizations. However, delay in implementing an effective process can be costly as pointed out in a December 2007 assessment of sub-prime litigation risk by Guy Carpenter & Company, LLC. In "What’s the State of Your State? E&O Risk Uneven across the Country," authors list six factors that give rise to litigation risk for real estate professionals (though noteworthy for other related parties, given the flurry of lawsuits now being filed). See below for excerpted text:

  • Percentage of mortgages in foreclosure
  • Percentage of subprime mortgages that are delinquent
  • Number of litigation attorneys per mortgage industry professional
  • Frequency of Truth in Lending lawsuits (per million households) through Q32006
  • Frequency of banking-related lawsuits (per million households) through Q32006
  • Extent to which a state is plaintiff-friendly, i.e., is deemed a “Judicial Hellhole” by the
    American Tort Reform Association (ATRA).

Mortgage bankers and real estate brokers may be getting pink slips but litigators are busier than ever. For retirement plan fiduciaries, it bears repeating. Ask external money managers if they have sub-prime problems, query about how they are addressing risk gaps and demand to know what lessons they have learned from the credit crisis.

Trackbacks (0) Links to blogs that reference this article Trackback URL
http://www.pensionriskmatters.com/admin/trackback/53859
Comments (0) Read through and enter the discussion with the form at the end
Fiduciary Leadership, LLC
929 White Plains Road
No. 377
Trumbull, CT 06611-3938
Phone: (203) 261-5519